Tony Hinchcliffe's Kill Tony Controversy

• 53:58Tim defends Tony Hinchcliffe as not hateful but says the joke was the worst decision a comedian could make in that moment.
• 54:16Tony's a roast comic and his style outside Kill Tony can be disturbing to people unfamiliar with his work.
• 54:43Kill Tony has launched careers for Black people, gay people, trans comics, and others who've traveled for the opportunity to be on the show.
• 55:09Tony has a heart and is a human being—reducing him to one wrong joke diminishes his actual contributions.
• 56:05Being a comedian means making choices, some good and some bad, and it's hard to see what the funny would have been in this case.
• 56:29Tim claims the burden of always being right about everything is why he doesn't have a Netflix special.
• 56:48Tim argues people focus on the wrong definition of 'bad'—using words people dislike rather than destroying families or personal harm.
• 57:35Society seems to accept any behavior as long as you say the right things and express the correct opinions.
• 58:48When everything becomes about having the right opinion packaged correctly, people lose sight of what actually matters.
• 59:38Tim insists you can't reduce Tony to a single sentence when his career has involved elevating people and providing pathways the industry wouldn't.
• 1:00:17People should be judged on the whole of what they've done, not just a few things here and there.

Kill TonyTony HinchcliffeJohn MulaneyMichael LehrerOlivia Munn