rant · moment 10 of 15

Cultural Appropriation and "Old Man River" at Karaoke

from #212 - Barnyard Creature | The Tim Dillon Show · #212

12 min

A long riff questioning cultural appropriation rules, wondering if he can sing "Old Man River" at karaoke given his damaged deep voice, imagining Erykah Badu singing "Danny Boy," and circling back to defend himself again over the apartment/roommate accusations.

In this bit12 moments
  • Tim reads an article about cultural appropriation and TikTok video going viral about slang, wondering why it matters at all.
  • There's something weird about white millennial women opening fried chicken restaurants, but it should be allowed—Portland took it too far closing burrito stands.
  • Tim's singing problem: as a former child actor and singer, cigarettes and hard living left him able to sing only one song well.
  • That song is "Old Man River" from Showboat, traditionally sung by Black performers, which is why singing it at karaoke raises the cultural appropriation question.
  • Tim performs "Old Man River" live to illustrate his point about being able to hit the notes and convey the emotional weight of the material.
  • If Erykah Badu sang "Danny Boy," nobody would call it cultural appropriation because of the oppression hierarchy, but that's a bad way to order society.
  • Fusion food works because chefs take French techniques and Asian flavors—cultures should add to each other, like the defunct Les Papilles in Manhattan.
  • When a young white girl raps badly, people cringe, but singing "Old Man River" at karaoke would show genuine understanding of pain and material.
  • Tim wonders if he should have sung "Old Man River" to his ex-roommate, a situation she apparently interpreted very differently than he did.
  • Two people witnessing the same event can have completely different experiences—like eyewitness testimony in murder cases, which is often unreliable.
  • Tim's roommate accused him of leaving out leftovers that attracted maggots and flies—he categorically denies this and may sue for defamation over the claim.
  • The maggot allegation is untrue, and Tim refuses to stay silent about being falsely accused of this.
Mentioned here

Erykah Baducultural appropriationOld Man RiverShowboatLes Bernardin

All 15 moments in this episode →