rant · moment 10 of 15

Twitter Pile-Ons, Virtue Signaling, and What Real Activism Looks Like

from You Can't Have Everything · #50

Audio-only archive episode — no video to seek.

4 min

Tim criticizes Twitter dunking culture and virtue signaling, argues real activism means giving up lucrative careers to help people, and complains about identity politics language around allyship and pride.

In this bit9 moments
  • 33:50Real activism means giving up lucrative careers—lawyers, doctors, people with skills—to work on behalf of oppressed people.
  • 34:12Tim argues against the paradigm that everything has to be solved immediately; systemic problems require time.
  • 35:14There are concrete ways to help—soup kitchens, work with the homeless, charities addressing starvation and climate—but people ignore them.
  • 35:30Identity politics has consumed activism so completely that going to help a homeless person gets met with accusations about being cisgender.
  • 35:49Articles now tell straight allies they can't attend pride without understanding five specific things, reducing solidarity to a gatekeeping game.
  • 36:21Being a feminist or an ally shouldn't be remarkable—it's just the baseline of being a good person.
  • 36:49Activism has become a competition in moral one-upmanship where everyone is still problematic and nobody is actually good enough.
  • 37:12The first pride was a police riot, which should be remembered when people police who belongs at pride events now.
  • 37:33Tim recalls actually showing up to pride with Russ Baker in Asli's chaps and maracas at the morning of the parade.
Mentioned here

Russ Baker

All 15 moments in this episode →