rant · moment 13 of 21

Dirty Wars, Drone Strikes as Propaganda, and Hollywood's Moral Dilemma Formula

from The Pilot! · #15

Audio-only archive episode — no video to seek.

5 min

Referencing the documentary Dirty Wars and Jeremy Scahill, Tim argues real drone warfare radicalizes victims' families, connects it to a shift in conservative foreign policy from Bush-era interventionism toward Trump-style isolationism, and mocks Hollywood's habit of giving 'good guys' just one bad decision instead of showing sustained monstrous behavior.

In this bit12 moments
  • 32:05Movies about drone strikes become people's primary source of understanding the subject, shaping their beliefs about civilian casualty minimization.
  • 32:25Tim questions whether the CIA is literally writing these films.
  • 32:37Collateral murder footage showed civilians being blown up while operators said to blow it up anyway, then the Pentagon covered it up completely.
  • 32:53Tim and Ray found it absurd that military decision-making is portrayed as complex deliberation when in reality it's just one person saying blow it up.
  • 33:29Most people build their worldview based on movies without realizing it's happening.
  • 33:40Eye in the Sky is an Orwellian title that frames surveillance and killing as benevolent oversight.
  • 34:29Dirty Wars documents Afghan families whose children were playing soccer when they got blown up, then those people hate America—and why wouldn't they?
  • 34:50Conservatives will blame madrasas for poisoning minds against America while ignoring torture on TV and drone strikes killing civilians.
  • 35:17Pat Buchanan's isolationist conservatism of the 90s is being resuscitated by Donald Trump, offering an alternative to neoconservative interventionism.
  • 36:16Hollywood uses a formula where a good person has to do one shady thing as a moral dilemma, when the reality is years of exploitation every single day.
  • 36:30Tim criticizes the moral dilemma framing of Hollywood success stories, using crude hyperbole about the actual sustained degradation required.
  • 36:44Tim emphasizes that exploitation isn't a one-time choice but continuous abuse that damages people permanently.
Mentioned here

Donald TrumpDirty Warsdrone strikesPaul WolfowitzEye in the SkyGeorge W. BushPat BuchananRichard PearlJulian AssangeJeremy ScahillRick Rowley

All 21 moments in this episode →